When it comes to grading a draft I tend to look at things a little bit differently than guys like Mel
Kiper and such. For example, if you have to go to the 7
th round to find a great pick, I'm not going to rank that draft as a good one. You shouldn't make your best pick with your 6
th, 7
th, or 8
th overall pick in an entire weekend of picks.
I'm also not going to give credit to a team for picking a good player if I think they could have picked a better one. Its just that simple.
Lastly, I'm not looking at next year's draft. Trading a pick this year to get something next year has nothing to do with my grades and vice
versa, you're not getting knocked any grades for trading next years picks to move up this year. Its all about this past weekend for me.
Without further ado,
thatguysports draft day grades.
Arizona Cardinals: C+
Some nice picks late, but I don't like Alan Branch at all, and Levi Brown in my opinion isn't a lock to be a superstar. Would've like to have seen them work on their defense a little bit more - they have an offense that is decent. Their defense is
swiss cheese.
Atlanta Falcons: D
I hate this draft. I think Jamaal Anderson is overrated and Chris Houston is going to be a bust. They didn't help their offense at all - another raw
WR is NOT what they need (Laurent Robinson), and they didn't help their offensive line much at all.
Baltimore Ravens: C
I'm not big on drafting a return specialist early in a draft unless its a
Daunte Hall type, but I don't think
Figurs is that guy.
Grubbs is a Guard, and no doubt he is a good one, but how hard is it to develop a Guard?
Their best pick?
Lleron McClain. Guy's a stud.
Buffalo Bills: B-
I like the
Posluszny pick where they got him but I despise the
Marshawn Lynch pick. He didn't do squat against teams that had defenses more stout than the crap the
Pac-10 rolls out week in and week out. That being said, John
Wendling was a great pick where they got him.
Carolina Panthers: A-
Great draft.
Beason is a stud. Dwayne Jarrett and Ryan Kalil will be solid
contributers if not Pro-Bowlers. Georgia DE Charles Johnson is solid as well.
Chicago Bears: C
I hate Greg Olsen. Their best pick was
Beekman from BC.
Cincinatti Bengals: C
Leon Hall was their best and only solid pick.
Cleveland Browns: A+
Sorry folks but you don't worry about next year's draft when you find a QB you love, AND who wants to play for you. Case and point with Cleveland.
Joe Thomas to anchor the line, Brady Quinn at QB, and Eric Allen at Corner.
Dallas Cowboys: B-
Anthony Spencer is a good counterpart to
Demarcus Ware, and James Marten at Tackle is solid.
Denver Broncos: C+
Jarvis Moss and not a whole lot else. Not enough improvement for a team that really faded down the stretch last year.
Detroit Lions: C-
Sure, they got Calvin Johnson. But Drew Stanton SUCKS with a capital SUCKS. Matt
Millen continues to have pictures of somebody - as that's the only way he keeps his job.
Green Bay Packers: D+
Not a big Justin Harrell fan. Not for where they drafted him.
Nobody else of merit.
Houston Texans: F
Okoye may be good, but if he becomes a pro-bowler, he's the only solid player they picked up yesterday.
Indianapolis Colts: B
As much as this pains me, its a good draft for Indy. I obviously love Gonzalez.
Daymeion Hughes will be a solid corner in their Tampa 2 system.
Jacksonville Jaguars: C-
Reggie Nelson and a bunch of guys who went too early. Not the kind of draft you write home about.
Kansas City Chiefs: B-
Dwayne
Bowe and Turk McBride will be solid players for them. Nice draft with limited picks for them this weekend.
Miami Dolphins: F
It doesn't get much worse for this team. Sure, Beck was one of my sleepers at QB but if you're going to pass on Brady Quinn for a
WR why not pick up the best one available? They basically used a 9
th overall pick to replace Wes
Welker. I'm not kidding.
Minnesota Vikings: A-
Adrian Peterson, enough said. Sidney Rice, enough said. Brian
Robison will be a Patrick Kearney/Jared Allen type in the NFL and they got him late. Great draft for Minny this year, although the fact they got their draft card in on time is still a feat for this franchise.
New England Patriots: C+
I'm not talking about the Randy Moss trade. They had two top 28 picks and only have Brandon
Mayweather to show for it. Why not take an LB with 28? You need youth at that position. Instead they trade for next year. I don't love what they did, but trading the 28
th pick for a 1st next year AND Randy Moss is
ok....i just wish they got younger on Defense.
New Orleans Saints: C-
Robert
Meachem and nothing else.
New York Giants: D+
Why not take Joe
Staley???? You NEED an OT for Eli Manning to succeed and you give him nothing. They only avoided an F by getting
DeOssie and Steve Smith. But passing on
Staley will haunt them for a long time.
New York Jets: B+
Granted, only 3 picks, but Darrelle
Revis was my top corner, and David Harris is one of the young
LB's I wanted to see the Patriots draft.
Oakland Raiders: C-
Jamarcus Russell will be a bust, and the rest is history. Best pick was Michael Bush.
Philadelphia Eagles: F
Horrible draft for this team. Kevin
Kolb will suck and you already have
McNabb.
Abiamiri isn't my guy, and Tony Hunt will be useless at the next level.
Pittsburgh
Steelers: B
Timmons will be great in their 3-4 and
Wodley is solid. Add to that a sleeper in Dallas Baker who is only hampered by his 40 time.
St. Louis Rams: B+
Another draft I real like. Typical "lunch pail guys" in
Carricker and Brian Leonard.
San Diego Chargers: C-
Craig Davis in the first round? Gross.
Weddle is their best pick.
San Francisco 49
ers: B+
Patrick Willis, my man Joe
Staley anchor a great draft. This team will be solid next year (which is why I don't love the Patriots trading for their 1st rounder next year). It should surprise nobody if San Fran wins 11 games next year.
Seattle
Seahawks: D
Useless. How's
Deion Branch you losers?
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: C+
Gaines Adams seemed to turn it on and off last year, but
Sabby Piscitelli was arguably the most "My guy" in the entire draft this year.
Tennessee Titans: D
Chris Henry is god awful. He'll actually make
Lendale White look like a good pro. Then draft 3
WR who are below average. Sick draft. I can't wait for Vince Young to fall on his face next year. Tennessee will be the most overrated team in the league next season.
Washington Redskins: C
1 for 1 is good. Blades may be a player if he can overcome his physical limitations.